Texas Rule 106 Substitute Service: A Step-by-Step Guide for Attorneys
Texas is a personal service state, which means a citation and petition have to reach a named person directly before a case can move forward. When a process server makes multiple attempts at a residence or business and still comes up without a direct personal service, the file either moves to substitute service under Rule 106(b) of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, or it stalls. The rule sounds simple on paper. In practice, the four attempts get all the attention, and the actual requirement sitting underneath them gets missed, which is exactly what got a young process server named Ricky pulled into his supervisor’s office. “Four attempts, no answer,” Jimmy told his young process server, Ricky. “That’s due diligence. That’s not a 106(b).” Ricky frowned. “But I made four attempts. Nobody answered.” “I’ve told you this three times now,” Jimmy said. “Due diligence just means you showed up and tried. A judge doesn’t care how many times you knocked if nobody ever confirmed the guy actually lives there. Someone at that residence has to look you in the eye, at least once out of your four attempts, and tell you the recipient lives there. That’s the whole rule. Without it, you don’t have a 106(b) request, you have four wasted trips.” Ricky still looked unconvinced, so Jimmy laid out the whole case. “Last month I had a defendant like that. First attempt, nothing. Second attempt, nothing. Third attempt, an old woman answers the door, arms crossed, tells me, ‘He’ll be home in two days. Now get off my porch,’ and shuts the door in my face. Fourth attempt, two days later, still nothing. Four attempts total, Ricky, and one of them, just one, gave me a resident confirming out loud that the defendant lives there. That’s what let me file the Texas Non-Service Affidavit in Support of Substitute Service under Rule 106. Not the four wasted trips on their own. The confirmation is what carries the motion.” How Does Rule 106 Substitute Service Work? (The Short Version) Rule 106(b) is what a Texas court uses when standard personal service, handing the citation and petition directly to the defendant, hasn’t worked. It lets an attorney ask a judge to authorize an alternative method, usually posting the documents at the defendant’s address and mailing a copy by certified mail. It’s not automatic. A judge has to sign off first, based on a sworn statement showing genuine attempts were made and the address is actually correct. Skip that step, and any posting or mailing you do on your own carries no legal weight. Step 1: Document Four Failed Attempts Texas doesn’t set a fixed number in the rule itself, but courts generally expect to see a documented pattern before granting a Rule 106(b) motion, and in practice that means a minimum of four attempts, spread across different days and times of day, including a weekend. One note on business defendants before you start: not every business situation needs Rule 106 at all. If the registered agent on file isn’t the owner, and that person or an authorized employee accepts documents normally, that’s just standard business service. Rule 106 comes into play specifically when the registered agent is the owner themselves and that person is the one avoiding you. Here’s the rookie mistake: treating avoidance as proof. A process server who sees someone bolt for the door, slam it, and cut the lights has documented exactly one thing, that person didn’t want to be seen. It doesn’t confirm who that person was. It doesn’t confirm they live there. A judge reading that account has no way to verify anything beyond “somebody appears to be avoiding contact.” That’s not enough on its own. What actually counts: • A resident, someone 16 or older who lives at the address, confirms the defendant lives there too, even indirectly, “she’s truck driving, back end of the week” counts just as much as a direct yes • A neighbor confirms the defendant’s residency, usually checked after the first attempt comes up empty • A named employee confirms the defendant works there and explains why they’re unavailable • Attempts spread across different days and times, not four visits at the same hour What kills the address entirely, not just the attempt: • “We don’t know this person,” or “this is a different business” • “They got fired, no longer works here” • “We’re renting this place, never heard of them” Answers like those don’t support a Rule 106 motion, they tell you the address is wrong. That’s a skip trace problem, not a substitute service problem. A few more things worth knowing. Confirmation doesn’t shortcut the count, if a resident confirms residency on attempt one, you still need three more attempts before filing. And if a property is gated or otherwise inaccessible, four unsuccessful attempts at getting past that gate still count toward your four, not being able to physically reach the door doesn’t mean the person doesn’t live there, it just means the attempts were unsuccessful for a different reason. Step 2: File the Sworn Statement and Motion Since Rule 106 was amended at the end of 2020, the supporting document is no longer technically called an affidavit. It can be a statement sworn before a notary or signed under penalty of perjury. The statement has to include: • The specific address where the defendant can probably be found • The dates, times, and outcomes of each attempt • The fact confirming residency, and who provided it The motion and the sworn statement are two separate documents, filed together. The motion asks the court to authorize an alternative method. The statement is what backs it up. Step 3: Wait on the Judge’s Ruling There’s no statutory deadline requiring a ruling by a specific date. Turnaround depends entirely on the court’s docket. Some judges sign an uncontested
Texas Rule 106 Substitute Service: A Step-by-Step Guide for Attorneys Read More »









